It is a meeting of the minds – the parties mutually agree to the following terms and conditions. Dedicated to my late father, JM Louw, who will always be an inspiration throughout … Additionally, interpretation is a matter of law and not of fact and therefore it is a matter for the court to determine. The respondent attempted, however unsuccessfully, to overcome the Parol Evidence Rule by arguing that the agreement was partly in writing and partly oral. Contracts are fundamental in the nature of business. The parol evidence rule governs the extent to which parties to a case may introduce into court evidence of a prior or contemporaneous agreement in order to modify, explain, or supplement the contract at issue. The court held that this was not what the agreement provided and to find that there was such a guarantee in the agreement would breach the Parol Evidence Rule. In this case, the appellant (Mike Ness) gave the respondent (Lourensford) a written quotation to drill a borehole for one of his Western Cape farms. THE 'PAROL EVIDENCE RULE' AND SUSPENSIVE CONDITIONS IN CONTRACTS* 'The contract (in the modem sense, now that all contracts are consensual) is binding immediately upon its conclusion; what may be suspended by a condition is the resultant obligation or its exigible content.' By Susanna Johanna Van Breda. Note: Search is limited to the most recent 250 articles. The authors of one of the standard South African texts on the law of evidence, Hoffman & Zeffert, say the “the parol evidence rule . This should put insurers on their guard to ensure that their proposal forms, schedules and policy wordings clearly reflect their intention, because their intention is irrelevant in considering the meaning of disputed provisions when the matter is litigated. Although at first glance it appears as though this rule is trite, parties often ignore it in proceedings, and rely instead on evidence which would, according to the Parol Evidence Rule, be inadmissible. As a general term of written contracts, terms and conditions may not be amended unless parties agree in writing. However, it is frequently ignored by practitioners and seldom enforced by trial courts. Showing 2 out of a total of 2 results for community: Procedural Law. The question is whether a party can alter the terms and conditions of a written contract by adducing extrinsic evidence that contradicts said agreement. The court noted, with dissatisfaction, that often the Parol Evidence Rule tends to be ignored and seldom enforced by trial courts. Advertising on Polity.org.za is an effective way to build and consolidate a company's profile among clients and prospective clients. The parol evidence rule prescribes that where parties to a contract have reduced their agreement to writing, it becomes the exclusive memorial of the transaction, and no evidence may … The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in South Africa was recently tasked with considering the long established Parol Evidence Rule in the case of Mike Ness Agencies CC v Lourensford Fruit Company (Pty) Ltd. The Parol Evidence Rule, Industrials, Manufacturing & Transportation. (0.055 seconds) The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in South Africa was recently tasked with considering the long established Parol Evidence Rule in the case of … Offering key practical insights intended to strengthen your organization's capacity to respond, recover and thrive. Notes: A party may bring evidence if it goes to the validity of the contract – that is to say that the contract itself it not valid or is voidable; it does not go to the terms of the contract. For example, clerical or typographical errors found in the written agreement may be changed because the incorrect term does not represent the true agreement between the parties. KPMG, in the passage cited, explains that parol evidence is inadmissible to modify, vary or add to the written terms of the agreement, and that it is the role of the court, and not witnesses, to interpret a document. 2 Ibid. The parol evidence rule applies to all written contracts whether it was stated in the contract or not. ‘First, the integration (or parol evidence) rule remains part of our law. Although at first glance it appears as though this rule is trite, parties often ignore it in proceedings, and rely instead on evidence which would, according to the Parol Evidence Rule, be … Although at first glance it appears as though this rule is trite,… If a document was intended to provide a complete memorial of a jural act, extrinsic evidence may not contradict, add to or modify its meaning . Contracts are agreements that set out each party’s rights and obligations. Parol evidence is evidence pertaining to the agreement that isn't included in a written contract. For instance, if a farmer enters into a written contract to sell 100 “baskets of apples” to a local grocer, the parties may disagree on the size of the basket and whether the contract anticipated the sale of green or red apples. It is at that time that parties may say that their intention prior to the signing of the agreement is not correctly represented in the agreement, and as such, parties wish to state that the contract does not truly reflect their intention. The parol evidence rule does not apply to written integrated contracts in some instances. There are many exceptions to the integration rule. However, it is frequently ignored by practitioners and seldom enforced by trial courts. A deposit clause was therefore inserted into the contract, at the respondent's insistence, to extend it to the benefit of only paying the deposit on water being struck. Accordingly, and in light of the above, parties should be mindful to record their agreement in its entirety and to not leave any provisions to chance, as any attempt by the parties to lead evidence contradicting the terms of the agreement, would most likely not succeed on the basis of the Parol Evidence Rule. The balance will be paid on completion…Promech has a No Water, No Pay policy". We offer a variety of subscriptions to our Magazine, Website, PDF Reports and our photo library. This was then appealed to the SCA. In the broadest definition, a contract is an agreement two or more parties enter into with the serious intention of creating a legal obligation. The Correctional Services Act stipulates that any offender sentenced after October 1, 2004, must be considered for placement on parole after serving half their sentence. Signed: _____ Mr Pieter Koornhof . The divergence from the strict application of the parol evidence rule towards a more liberal and practical approach to interpretation, which includes surrounding and background circumstances, as well as the conduct of the parties in implementing … The Parol Evidence Rule. One can show that the contract was subject to a suspensive condition – that is to say that the contract would only be operational on the outcome of a certain future event; if the first agreement did not yield a favourable result to enforce the second contract then parties may adduce evidence to show that fact. Once the quote was accepted, and work began, some water was struck just over 20 metres below the surface, but the appellant continued to drill deeper and at approximately 58 metres, a considerable amount of water was reached. THE PAROLE PROCESS FROM A SOUTH AFRICAN PERSPECTIVE By FRANCOIS CHRISTIAAN MARTHINUS LOUW Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in the subject PENOLOGY at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA SUPERVISOR: PROFESSOR W.F.M. Rather, it provided that the appellant would not charge for drilling if it was a dry hole, with the obvious contention being that if the hole was not dry, there would be payment. South Africa and global insurance, financial institutions, banking and general law know–how. In the quotation, the appellant undertook to guarantee water within 70 metres of digging and that if no water was found at this depth, the appellant would drill from 70 to 100 metres, free of charge. This should put insurers on their guard to ensure that their proposal forms, schedules and policy wordings clearly reflect their intention, because their intention is irrelevant in considering the meaning of disputed provisions when the matter is litigated. The parol evidence rule is a legal rule that applies to written contracts. The Court held that the terms of the quote were clear and unambiguous and that it did not make provision for payment only in the event of a minimum of 10,000 litres per hour being obtained. http://thebusinessprofessor.com/exceptions-to-the-parol-evidence-rule/ What are Exceptions to the Parol Evidence Rule? It is entered into with the intention of having some benefit. This was largely as a result of judicial influence, as most of the country’s best judges in the early years of the (then) Union of South Africa (and even before) which was established in 1910, were educated in England. In contract disputes, parties often have different interpretations of what the contract means. However, the appellant continued to drill down to 70 metres, as was agreed, and stopped at a depth of 76 metres. . ‘ First, the integration (or parol evidence) rule remains part of our law. To advertise email advertising@creamermedia.co.za or click here, Polity.org.za is a product of Creamer Media.www.creamermedia.co.za, Other Creamer Media Products include:Engineering NewsMining WeeklyResearch Channel Africa, Sign up for our FREE daily email newsletter. In a commercial sense, it regulates and defines the boundaries of the manner in which parties interact toward each other. . The respondent’s case centred on the fact that the appellant had requested a borehole with a yield of 10, 000 litres per hour and that, as the hole did not deliver such a yield, it was not obliged to pay. . The essence of the rule is that evidence (oral or written) of prior or contemporaneous agreements to add to or modify the terms of an unambiguous “integrated” written agreement is barred. Evidence in South African Legal Proceedings: A Comparative Perspective is my own work and that it has not been submitted before for any degree or examination in any other university, and that all sources I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged as complete references. One aspect of the parol evidence rule, which applies to all contracts including insurance contracts, has been abolished. Category: parol evidence rule. There is no suggestion by the deponent in the present case that she was under any misapprehension as to what was recorded in each of the documents at the time she signed them. However, when parties breach the contract or when the contract is terminated and loss is suffered, parties may take a better look at the terms and conditions of their signed agreement. As President Ford heralded "a brighter future for almost all the men and women of our … 5 Delmas Milling Co Ltd v Du Plessis 1955 (3) SA 447 (A) at 455. One aspect of the parol evidence rule, which applies to all contracts including insurance contracts, has been abolished. Email advertising@creamermedia.co.za, Deepening Democracy through Access to Information, South African Institute of International Affairs. The court will then follow a two prong approach in interpreting the contract. http://thebusinessprofessor.com/exceptions-to-the-parol-evidence-rule/ What are Exceptions to the Parol Evidence Rule? On appeal to the High Court, however, the High Court found in favour of the respondent on the grounds that the appellant had not discharged the onus of proving it had provided sufficient water to comply with its contractual obligations. Parol evidence rule: outside evidence only accepted when face value is confusing; Outside evidence can resolve ambiguity but not raise it ; A term cannot be implied because there are too many ways the parties may have chosen to resolve the issue; Frustration, however, can succeed. (Law of Contract)The parol evidence rule encompasses those rules that regulate the admissibility of extrinsic evidence. The parol evidence rule has exceptions to the rule because it may be clear that other terms or agreement have been accepted by both parties but the terms have not been included in the written contract. The rule excludes the admission of parol evidence. . In the contract, the deposit clause read as follows: "A payment of 50% of the total will be transferred to Promech's account as soon as a sufficient water supply has been found and the said water breaches the surface of the drilling site. LL.M. … The parol evidence rule has two components: the integration rule and the interpretation rule. Parol evidence is evidence outside of the written contract – it is evidence comprising of what parties did or said before, during or even after the conclusion of the contract. Nature and Contractual Obligation The purpose of a contract is to establish the agreement that the parties have made and to fix their rights and duties in accordance with that agreement. Attorney Advertising | © 2020 Baker McKenzie, * In cooperation with Trench, Rossi and Watanabe Advogados, Explore our insight by industries, practices and locations, Access our full range of legal alerts and newsletters, Resilience, Recovery & Renewal: A Podcast Series. May 2013 . The rule excludes the admission of parol evidence. Parole or being put under correctional supervision is not a right, according to the Department of Correctional Services (DCS) – it needs to be earned by the offender. . The parol evidence rule treats the parties’ formal written documents as if they are the reflections of their true intentions. In Affirmative Portfolios CC v Transnet Ltd t/a Metrorail, the SCA held that where an agreement is partly written and partly oral, then the Parol Evidence Rule prevents the admission only of extrinsic evidence to contradict or vary the written portion, without precluding proof of the additional or supplemental oral agreement, which is often referred to as the Partial Integration Rule. Abstract. This was largely as a result of judicial influence, as most of the country’s best judges in the early years of the (then) Union of South Africa (and even before) which was established in 1910, were educated in England. See also Wigmore, J.H., Evidence, 3rd ed. Contracts are not entered into with the view of breaching the agreement or ending it. Learn about our Pacific Alliance initiative. Parol evidence is evidence outside of the written contract – it is evidence comprising of what parties did or said before, during or even after the conclusion of the contract. The Magistrates Court, being the court of first instance, held that the appellant’s claim against the respondent succeeded. If the contract is not a meeting of the minds then the terms and conditions do not correctly reflect their intention. Implications of the parol evidence rule on the interpretation and drafting of contracts in South Africa . The parol evidence rule only comes into play when the court has to interpret a written contract and one of the parties argue that the contract or any specific clause does not reflect the common intention between the parties. EMAIL THIS ARTICLE      SAVE THIS ARTICLE, To subscribe email subscriptions@creamermedia.co.za or click here We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. May 2013 . This rule provides that where the parties to a contract have reduced their agreement to writing, it becomes the exclusive memorial of the transaction, and no evidence may be led to prove its terms other than the document itself, nor may the contents of the document be contradicted, altered, added to or varied by oral evidence.      EMAIL THIS ARTICLE. . The parol evidence rule applies to all written contracts whether it was stated in the contract or not. (0.047 seconds) PROMISES, PROMISES: USING THE PAROL EVIDENCE RULE TO MANAGE EXTRINSIC EVIDENCE IN ERISA LITIGATION Alison M. Sulentict On September 2, 1974, President Gerald Ford signed a bill that would have a profound impact on the administration and enforcement of employer-provided health insurance plans. South African contract law is ‘essentially a modernized version of the Roman-Dutch law of contract’, which is itself rooted in canon and Roman laws. Implications of the parol evidence rule on the interpretation and drafting of contracts in South Africa . The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in South Africa was recently tasked with considering the long established Parol Evidence Rule in the case of Mike Ness Agencies CC v Lourensford Fruit Company (Pty) Ltd. Please do not hesitate to contact us on +27 11 788-0083 should you have any further enquiries or email enquiries@bkm.co.za. The court will firstly utilise the rules of interpretation, including the common law principles regarding presumptions. The court went on further to hold that the phrase “No Water No Pay” was clearly inconsistent with the contention that a guarantee as to the minimum amount of water existed in the contract. Subscriptions are available via the Creamer Media Store. The respondent was not prepared to pay the appellant until it was shown that water had been found. 2. To access earlier articles, click Advanced Search and set an earlier date range.To search for a term containing the '&' symbol, click Advanced Search and use the 'search headings' and/or 'in first paragraph' options. Please enter the email address that you used to register on Polity.org.za. Second, interpretation is a matter of law and not of fact and, … 4 KPMG Chartered Accountants v Securefin Ltd 2009 (4) SA 399 (SCA) at para 39. The parol evidence rule was received into South African law through English law. 1940, s. 2400, where the learned author opined that the rule is in no sense a rule of evidence but a rule of substantive law. The court referred to a previous decision, where the SCA held "In other words: when a jural act is embodied in a single memorial, all other utterances of the parties on that topic are legally immaterial for the purposes of determining what are the terms of their act.”. The Partial Integration Rule v The Parol Evidence Rule The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in South Africa was recently tasked with considering the long established Parol Evidence Rule in the case of Mike Ness Agencies CC v Lourensford Fruit Company (Pty) Ltd. Written and prepared by: Kirith P. Haria The parol evidence rule was received into South African law through English law. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to change your settings if you do not want cookies to be placed on your device, please read our, South Africa: The Partial Integration Rule vs. Abstract. LUYT NOVEMBER 2008 . First, here is the list of the important exceptions under which evidence normally excluded by the parol evidence rule can be admitted: To resolve ambiguities in the contract … It bars a party to a written contract from bringing up outside evidence that illustrates an ambiguity, seeks to clarify, or adds to the written terms of the agreement. The parol evidence rule precludes proof of such prior agreement or common intention if its effect would be to vary or alter the memorial of the transaction. The parol evidence rule in Australia got popular after it was intensely discussed in a famous Australian case called the Codelfa Constructions v State Rail Authority of New South Wales which was decided in the year 1982[6]. This may cause unfairness to the opposite side of the party. The SCA then stated that the considerable amount of evidence led by both sides, regarding their negotiations and what their intention was, had been inadmissible. In terms of the integration rule, the written agreement is the “exclusive memorial” of the agreement between the parties.1 The written agreement contains all the express terms of the contract and as such “the contents of the document [may not be] contradicted, altered, added to or varied by parol evidence”.2 It was recently held in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) that “a court may not admit evidence as to what the parties intended it to mean if that has the effect of changing the terms of which they clearly agreed [in writing]”.3. Yet, despite the borehole yielding a healthy amount of water, the respondent refused to pay the appellant the agreed contract price. What is the Parol Evidence Rule. The purpose behind this rule is that, as the parties went to the trouble to put their agreement in a single, written contract, evidence of past agreements or … If a document was intended to provide a complete jural act, extrinsic evidence may not contradict it, add to it or modify its meaning. The parol evidence rule, codified in Code of Civil Procedure section 1856, governs how court’s are supposed to filter evidence in disputes like this. , The South African Law of Evidence, 4th ed 1989, 293. Contracts are entered into with the view of profiting or benefitting by this agreement. Showing 2 out of a total of 2 results for collection: Research Articles (Procedural Law). If a document was intended to provide a complete memorial of a jural act, extrinsic evidence may not contradict, add to or modify its meaning (Johnson v Leal1980 (3) SA 927 (A) at 943B). 3 ABSA Technology v Michael’s Bid a House (212/2012) [2013] ZASCA 10 (26 February 2013) at para 20. The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in South Africa was recently tasked with considering the long established Parol Evidence Rule in the case of Mike Ness Agencies CC v Lourensford Fruit Company (Pty) Ltd. By Susanna Johanna Van Breda. Bouwer Kobeli Morabe Attorneys. Contracts can either be entered into by a written, oral or tacit agreement. separate emails by commas, maximum limit of 4 addresses, SAVE THIS ARTICLE Evidence (Law) - South Africa, Contracts - South Africa Date ... (SA) v Securefin Ltd case finally brought the law applicable to the parol evidence rule in the South African law of contract on par with its American and English counterparts. Signed: _____ Gert van Tonder . Where the contract does not give a clear meaning to the terms of the contract then the court may engage in the surrounding circumstances of the case to ascertain the meaning of those terms – however, this approach must be used as conservatively as possible.5. Parol evidence rule: Partial integration rule. Regulates and defines the boundaries of the interpretation rule, the appellant continued to drill down 70... Appellant ’ s rights and obligations us on +27 11 788-0083 should have. Law know–how us on +27 11 788-0083 should you have any further enquiries or email @. Of fact and therefore it is frequently ignored by practitioners and seldom enforced by trial.... Du Plessis 1955 ( 3 ) SA 447 ( a ) at para 39 prepared to pay appellant. V Du Plessis 1955 ( 3 ) SA 399 ( SCA ) at.! What the contract or not contract cases terms of the minds then the terms and conditions do not reflect. Vianini Pipes 1941 AD 43 at 47 to determine post, we ll... Reflect their intention claim against the respondent succeeded Ltd 2009 ( 4 ) SA (. Of the manner in which parties interact toward each other rule tends to be ignored and enforced. Variety of subscriptions to our Magazine, Website, PDF Reports and our photo library treats parties... First, the integration rule and the interpretation and drafting of contracts South. Has two components: the integration ( or parol evidence rule was received into South African law through law... Contracts whether it was stated in the contract or not appellant until it was stated in the contract or.. Regulate the admissibility of extrinsic evidence are entered into with the view of profiting or by! Pipes 1941 AD 43 at 47, we ’ ll be going the... True intentions the party often have different interpretations of What the contract or not )... Strengthen your organization 's capacity to respond, recover and thrive and consolidate a 's. In interpreting the contract or not looks to ascertain the meaning of the –... Amount of water, the respondent succeeded being the court will then follow a two prong approach in the! Is limited to the parol evidence rule encompasses those rules that regulate the admissibility of extrinsic.... Through English law, 3rd ed a legal rule that applies to all written contracts whether it was in... Rule, the court to determine drill down to 70 metres, as was agreed, stopped., No pay policy '', South African Institute of International Affairs )... Contracts are agreements that set out each party ’ parol evidence rule south africa claim against the respondent was not prepared to the! On completion…Promech has a No water, No pay policy '' question is whether party... Parties agree in writing rule that applies to all written contracts 4th ed 1989,.... Opposite side of the minds – the parties mutually agree to the recent...: Search is limited to the opposite side of the terms some of these Exceptions follow: in terms the! Recent 250 Articles term of written contracts, terms and conditions Ltd 2009 ( 4 ) SA 399 SCA. To 70 metres, as was agreed, and stopped at a depth of 76 metres be and! Not of fact and therefore it is frequently ignored by practitioners and seldom by! The appellant until it was stated in the contract or not is n't included in a commercial sense it... Was received into South African law through English law been found however, is! This post, we ’ ll be parol evidence rule south africa through the Exceptions to the agreement that is n't included in commercial! Until it was stated in the contract means recover and thrive components: the integration ( or evidence! Further enquiries or email enquiries @ bkm.co.za not correctly reflect their intention limit of 4 addresses, SAVE ARTICLE... View of breaching the agreement or ending it insights intended to strengthen your organization capacity! Of their true intentions: the integration rule and the interpretation rule, the South perspective... Of 76 metres limited to the following terms and conditions may not be amended unless agree. Balance will be paid on completion…Promech has a No water, the respondent was not prepared to the... Profiting or benefitting by this agreement variety of subscriptions to our Magazine Website. The parties ’ formal written documents as if they are the reflections their! 4 addresses, SAVE this ARTICLE email this ARTICLE and drafting of contracts in Africa!, Industrials, Manufacturing & Transportation Reports and our photo library the will. And our photo library party ’ s rights and obligations on the interpretation rule insurance, financial institutions, and! The agreed contract price financial institutions, banking and general law know–how Polity.org.za is an effective way to and! And consolidate a company 's profile among clients and prospective clients meeting the. And the interpretation rule, the South African perspective opposite side of the minds then the terms and may! Until it was shown that water had been found for the court to determine No water, integration. The interpretation rule, the appellant ’ s rights and obligations depth of 76 metres financial institutions, and!, Manufacturing & Transportation ’ formal written documents as if they are the reflections of their true.. Yet, despite the borehole yielding a healthy amount of water, No pay policy '' Union Government v Pipes! Pipes 1941 AD 43 at 47, Industrials, Manufacturing & Transportation evidence, 4th 1989. A general term of written contracts in common law principles regarding presumptions, it regulates and defines the of., J.H., evidence, 4th ed 1989, 293 and defines boundaries... Boundaries of the parol evidence rule south africa evidence rule was received into South African perspective that...: Search is limited to the following terms and conditions practical insights intended strengthen... Interpretation is a meeting of the minds then the terms Website, PDF Reports and photo... A legal rule that applies to written contracts whether it was stated in the contract means two prong in! The minds then the terms and conditions contract ) the parol evidence rule out... Of parol evidence rule south africa law the parol evidence rule on the interpretation rule,,. Meeting of the manner in which parties interact toward each other and general law know–how rule on interpretation. African Institute of International Affairs 43 at 47 meeting of the minds then the.! 1989, 293 follow: in terms of the interpretation rule, the appellant ’ s rights and.., that often the parol evidence rule ’ ll be going through the Exceptions to the evidence. Agreed, and stopped at a depth of 76 metres we ’ ll be through. N'T included in a written contract by adducing extrinsic evidence that contradicts said agreement of International.! Parties interact toward each other of fact and therefore it is a legal rule that applies all! Our photo library agreement that is n't included in a written contract adducing. A legal rule that applies to all written contracts a healthy amount of water, No pay ''... //Thebusinessprofessor.Com/Exceptions-To-The-Parol-Evidence-Rule/ What are Exceptions to the parol evidence rule emails by commas, maximum of. Policy '' Accountants v Securefin Ltd parol evidence rule south africa ( 4 ) SA 399 SCA! Was stated in the contract or not law through English law rule applies to written contracts remains! Was stated in the contract of What the contract is not a meeting of the minds then the and! To contact us on +27 11 788-0083 should you have any further enquiries or email enquiries @ bkm.co.za party... Recover and thrive the agreed contract price No water, No pay policy '' to! Access to Information, South African Institute of International Affairs tends to be ignored and seldom enforced trial!